Differences and Comparison: CVD vs. HPHT Lab-Grown Diamonds

Lab-grown diamonds are shining brighter than ever as a sustainable and ethical alternative to their natural counterparts. They offer all the sparkle, strength, and beauty of natural diamonds without the environmental or ethical concerns of traditional mining.

But here's the thing—not all lab-grown diamonds are created equal. Two main methods to grow these gems are Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) and High Pressure High Temperature (HPHT). Each of these methods bring its own unique qualities to the table. If you're considering lab-grown diamonds, it’s essential to understand the key differences between CVD and HPHT. These growth processes shape the diamond itself and influence factors like clarity, color, and price.

Let’s dive into the HPHT vs. CVD debate and explore how these diamonds are made, what sets them apart, and which might best fit you.

The HPHT (High Pressure, High Temperature) Diamond

The HPHT method is one of the most established techniques used to create lab-grown diamonds, and it closely mimics the conditions under which natural diamonds form deep within the Earth. In the HPHT process, a small diamond seed is placed in a high-pressure chamber alongside pure carbon. It is subjected to intense pressure and heat, which causes the carbon atoms to crystallize, forming a diamond around it. 

The process aims to replicate the environment found 150-200 kilometers beneath the Earth’s surface, where natural diamonds are created. Over time, this leads to the formation of a high-quality diamond with the same physical, chemical, and optical properties as a mined one.

Stages of HPHT Diamond Growing Method:

The HPHT method has three key stages: preparation, growth, and cooling. Each stage plays a vital role in determining the final characteristics of the diamond, such as its shape, clarity, and color.

• Preparation 

The process begins with carefully preparing the growth chamber, where a tiny diamond seed is placed alongside pure carbon in graphite. In addition to carbon, metal catalysts such as nickel, cobalt, or iron are introduced into the chamber. These catalysts help reduce the energy required for the diamond to form and play a significant role in controlling the diamond's growth rate. The seed is placed in the chamber's center, surrounded by the carbon source. The chamber is then sealed and placed inside a press designed to withstand extremely high pressure and temperature.

• Growth 

The growth stage is where the magic happens. Inside the chamber, the carbon is subjected to pressures as high as 725,000 pounds per square inch and temperatures exceeding 2,000 degrees Celsius. Under these extreme conditions, the carbon atoms begin to break down and dissolve into the metal catalyst. As the carbon cools and settles, the atoms attach to the diamond seed. The process of growth can take several days to weeks, depending on the size and quality of the diamond being produced. The metal catalysts facilitate the movement of carbon atoms. The result is a diamond crystal with a cubic or octahedral shape, often exhibiting some color variations or inclusions due to the metal catalysts used in the process.

• Cooling 

After the growth phase, the diamond must cool slowly and under controlled conditions to stabilize the crystal structure. The cooling stage is critical, as rapid changes in temperature can cause cracks or other defects in the diamond. During cooling, the pressure and temperature within the chamber are gradually reduced to room conditions, allowing the diamond to retain its solid form.

Any remaining metal catalysts are then dissolved or removed from the surface of the diamond. 

Characteristics of HPHT Diamonds: 

HPHT diamonds typically have a cubic or octahedral shape, similar to naturally occurring diamonds. However, due to the use of metal catalysts, HPHT diamonds often display a slight yellowish or brownish tint. 

Additionally, HPHT diamonds may contain metallic inclusions, which are visible under magnification and can influence the diamond's magnetic properties.

While these inclusions do not affect the overall durability of the diamond, they do impact the diamond’s clarity and color.

Next, let’s get into the CVD lab-grown diamonds process, which presents a distinct contrast in both method and outcome compared to HPHT diamonds. 

Explore the widest collection of lab-grown diamonds at Everyday. 

The CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition) Diamond 

The CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition) method is a more recent innovation in the world of lab-grown diamonds, offering a high level of control over the quality and characteristics of the diamond produced. CVD begins with a tiny diamond seed placed inside a vacuum chamber, which is then filled with a carbon-rich gas, such as methane or hydrogen. The gasses are broken down and settle onto the diamond seed. This method allows for a slower formation of the diamond, which generally leads to higher clarity and fewer imperfections compared to HPHT diamonds.

Stages of CVD Diamond Growing Method

These stages allow for precise control over the environment in which the diamonds are grown, leading to remarkable clarity and purity.

• Chamber Setup 

The CVD process begins with the setup of a sealed vacuum chamber, designed to create the ideal low-pressure environment necessary for diamond growth. A small diamond seed is placed inside the chamber, usually a thin slice of an HPHT or natural diamond, which acts as the foundation for the diamond to grow. The vacuum inside the chamber eliminates contaminants and keeps the growth process clean. This setup is crucial, as even slight impurities in the chamber can lead to imperfections in the final diamond.

• Gas Introduction 

Once the chamber is prepared, carbon-rich gasses, such as methane or hydrogen, are introduced. These gasses serve as the source of carbon for the diamond. The introduction of these gasses marks the beginning of the growth phase, where the carbon atoms will slowly build onto the diamond seed.

At this stage, no extreme heat or pressure is used, setting CVD apart from the HPHT method.

• Plasma Formation 

The carbon-rich gasses are then activated by high-energy microwaves, creating plasma. This plasma breaks the gas molecules apart, into carbon atoms. These atoms attach themselves to the seed crystal. The carbon atoms within this plasma cloud are highly reactive, allowing them to bond easily with the seed crystal and form a diamond structure.

• Diamond Growth

As the carbon atoms from the plasma begin to settle onto the diamond seed, they bond in a diamond lattice structure. This growth process happens slowly, taking days or even weeks to produce a diamond of significant size. The slow and controlled nature of the CVD method ensures that the diamond grows in even layers, resulting in a more uniform and pure crystal. 

This method also allows for better control over the diamond’s color and clarity. If a colorless diamond is desired, careful adjustments to the gas mixture are made to avoid nitrogen, which can introduce color into the diamond.

Characteristics of CVD Diamonds 

CVD diamonds are known for their exceptional purity and are often colorless or near-colorless. Because the process occurs in a clean environment without the use of metal catalysts, they are free from the metallic inclusions that are commonly found in HPHT diamonds. This leads to diamonds that are typically of higher clarity and have fewer internal flaws.

One of the defining features of these diamonds is their lack of magnetism unlike the HTPT diamonds. This is an important distinction for those concerned about the purity and properties of their diamonds.

In terms of color, CVD lab-grown diamonds are often superior to HPHT diamonds, particularly when it comes to producing colorless stones. 

Having explored the CVD lab-grown diamond process, it’s now time to directly compare these two methods. Understanding these differences will give you a clearer picture of what to expect when choosing between HPHT vs. CVD diamonds.

Comparison of CVD and HPHT Diamonds

When comparing HPHT vs. CVD diamonds, several differences emerge in their formation processes, physical characteristics, and final appearance.

• Differences in the Formation Process

The most significant difference between HPHT and CVD diamonds lies in how they are formed. HPHT diamonds are created by replicating the intense pressure and heat found deep within the Earth. This method compresses carbon into a diamond structure using high-temperature and high-pressure conditions. On the other hand, CVD diamonds are grown layer by layer in a controlled environment using a chemical reaction between glasses and plasma.

• Variation in Temperature and Pressure Conditions

The temperature and pressure conditions for growing HPHT vs. CVD diamonds differ considerably. HPHT requires extreme pressures and temperatures to simulate the conditions found deep within the Earth’s mantle. 

CVD, in contrast, grows diamonds in a vacuum chamber with much lower pressure and temperature.

This difference significantly impacts the clarity and purity of the diamond, as CVD diamonds generally have fewer inclusions and more consistent color.

• Speed of Growth

The speed at which diamonds grow also varies between these two methods. HPHT diamonds tend to grow more quickly due to the high-intensity conditions under which they are formed. The process can be completed in a matter of days or weeks, depending on the size and quality of the diamond. 

CVD diamonds, on the other hand, grow more slowly and methodically. The layer-by-layer growth process takes longer—typically several weeks or more. 

As a result, CVD diamonds often emerge with fewer inclusions and require less post-growth treatment.

• Visual Characteristics

One of the most noticeable differences in HTHP vs. CVD diamonds are their visual characteristics. HPHT diamonds often contain metallic inclusions from the metal catalysts used during the growth process. These inclusions can affect the diamond’s clarity and give it a slight yellow or brown tint. 

CVD lab-grown diamonds, by contrast, are typically purer, have fewer inclusions, and also tend to be colorless or near-colorless. Because the process does not rely on metal catalysts, CVD diamonds are free from metallic impurities, resulting in a higher clarity rating. 

• Price Comparison

CVD diamonds may be slightly more expensive due to the slower, more precise growth process, which typically results in higher quality and fewer inclusions. 

HPHT diamonds are generally more affordable but may have more inclusions and a greater need for post-growth treatments, which can influence the overall cost.

The price difference between CVD and HPHT diamonds ultimately comes down to factors like size, quality, and the amount of post-production work required. 

Explore timeless elegance at affordable prices by shopping for Type II Diamonds at Everyday.

However, beyond these technical comparisons, it’s also important to consider the ethical and environmental benefits of lab-grown diamonds. Understanding the sustainability and ethical implications of HPHT vs. CVD diamonds can further guide your decision.

Ethical and Environmental Considerations

In addition to the technical differences between HPHT vs. CVD diamonds, the ethical and environmental aspects of lab-grown diamonds are key factors that appeal to many consumers today.

• CVD and HPHT Diamonds’ Environmental Benefits

One of the most significant advantages of lab-grown diamonds, whether produced via HPHT or CVD, is the reduced environmental footprint compared to traditional diamond mining. Mining involves extracting diamonds from the Earth, which requires the displacement of massive amounts of soil, deforestation, and the consumption of large quantities of water and energy. 

In contrast, CVD and HPHT diamonds are grown in controlled laboratory environments, and are seen as more energy-efficient, minimizing land disturbance and reducing resource use. 

• Ethical Advantages Over Natural Diamonds

Historically, the diamond mining industry has been associated with conflict diamonds—also known as blood diamonds—financed by unethical practices in war-torn regions. 

In addition to fueling conflicts, diamond mining can exploit laborers, often subjecting them to unsafe working conditions and unfair wages.

By choosing a lab-grown diamond, whether CVD or HPHT, consumers can avoid supporting these harmful practices as they are created in controlled laboratory settings rather than extracted from the ground. 

Explore Everyday’s stunning collection of ethically-sourced diamonds.

• Sustainable Practices in Lab-Grown Diamond Production

The diamond-growing industry is increasingly adopting sustainable practices, especially in the CVD lab-grown diamond sector. 

As demand for sustainable luxury grows, producers are focusing on reducing their carbon footprint,  and are now certified as "carbon-neutral" for recycling gasses in the CVD process, and utilizing renewable energy sources for production. 

Sustainable practices in HPHT production are also improving. HPHT labs are making strides in energy efficiency, with some adopting cleaner energy sources to mitigate their environmental impact.

Let’s explore how these factors come into play when making your final choice between HPHT vs. CVD diamonds.

Choosing Between CVD and HPHT Diamonds

Both methods produce stunning lab-grown diamonds, but each comes with its unique characteristics, making it important to choose the one that best aligns with your preferences and budget

• Clarity and Color

Clarity and color are primary considerations when choosing between CVD vs. HPHT diamonds. CVD diamonds tend to have fewer inclusions and are often colorless, making them ideal for those prioritizing purity.

HPHT diamonds, while slightly more prone to inclusions and color variations due to the metal catalysts used in their formation, can still be excellent in clarity and often undergo treatments to enhance their appearance. 

• Budget Considerations

For buyers on a budget, HPHT diamonds tend to be more affordable than CVD diamonds due to their quicker growth process. While both types of lab-grown diamonds are cheaper than natural ones, HPHT diamonds often come at a lower cost, especially in larger carats unlike CVD. 

Shop Everyday’s affordable and beautiful diamond collection!

• Availability and Size

HPHT diamonds are often more readily available in larger sizes, thanks to their faster growth process, making them a better option for those seeking bigger diamonds without breaking the bank. 

CVD diamonds may take longer to grow and are more commonly found in smaller sizes, but they offer superior quality and fewer inclusions. Both CVD and HPHT diamonds come in various shapes and cuts, ensuring you have a wide range of options, whether you prefer round, oval, or cushion cuts. 

Customize your jewelry to perfectly match your style with Everyday!

HPHT vs. CVD Lab-Grown Diamonds: A Comprehensive Comparison

To make the comparison even more precise, here’s a summary table you can refer to:

Choosing the Right Diamond for You

When deciding between CVD vs. HPHT diamonds, consider what matters most to you—clarity, size, budget, or overall quality. CVD diamonds offer exceptional purity and fewer inclusions, making them ideal for those seeking high clarity and colorless stones. 

On the other hand, HPHT diamonds provide excellent value, especially if you're looking for larger diamonds at a more affordable price. Both options are ethical, sustainable alternatives to natural diamonds, so weigh your preferences carefully. 

Ultimately, choosing between HPHT Vs. CVD diamonds should align with your personal values, budget, and aesthetic desires to ensure you get the perfect diamond that meets your needs. Visit Everyday, to find the best quality jewelry made with superior Type II diamonds. You can also contact us to visit our offline stores in multiple locations.