Understanding Synthetic vs. Natural Diamonds

Many people are intrigued yet confused about what exactly synthetic or natural diamonds are and how they differ from the ones mined from the earth.

While traditional diamonds have long been the standard, advancements in technology have allowed for the creation of lab-grown counterparts, which offer intriguing possibilities. 

This article dives into understanding synthetic and lab-grown diamonds, tracing their history, and distinguishing them from their natural counterparts.

Overview Of Synthetic and Lab-Grown Diamonds

When people hear about synthetic or lab-grown diamonds, they often wonder what these terms really mean. Essentially, both refer to diamonds that laboratories create rather than naturally form beneath the Earth’s surface.

Scientists have figured out how to replicate the conditions that cause diamonds to form in nature but in a controlled lab setting. Thanks to advances in technology, these lab-grown diamonds are created to have the same properties as natural ones.

Lab-grown diamonds have the same chemical, physical, and optical properties as natural diamonds, featuring the same carbon atom structure.

Looking for your perfect diamond? Try our jewelry firsthand with our Try at Home service! 

To make these diamonds, two main methods are used: the High-Pressure, High-Temperature (HPHT) technique and the Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) method.

These processes allow the production of high-quality diamonds with minimal impurities, as opposed to natural diamonds, which take billions of years to form and often have flaws due to their complex formation process.

Understanding these modern techniques is rooted in the early attempts at creating synthetic diamonds, which laid the groundwork for today's advancements.

Early Attempts and Breakthroughs in Diamond Synthesis

The quest to synthesize diamonds has deep roots going back to the late 19th century when the scientific community first became fascinated with the idea of creating these precious stones in 

laboratories. 

In 1797, Smithson Tennant's discovery that diamonds were actually a form of carbon set off a wave of experiments dedicated to replicating this transformation.

• Early Experiments

During the 1880s, James Hannay embarked on particularly bold and dangerous attempts by sealing organic materials with lithium inside iron tubes and applying heat. 

Despite the frequent explosive failures, these experiments marked some of the earliest significant efforts to replicate diamond formation artificially. 

Another notable figure, Henri Moissan, in 1893 tried dissolving carbon in molten iron to produce diamonds, but his results were inconsistent and did not lead to conclusive success.

• The Breakthrough

The real breakthrough occurred much later, in 1954, when Tracy Hall and Herbert Strong led General Electric's 'Project Superpressure' and successfully created synthetic diamonds. 

This marked a pivotal moment as they used a high-pressure belt press to subject graphite to intense heat and pressure, finally overcoming decades of failed attempts.

• Advancements in Technology

As technology evolved, General Electric developed a method in the 1970s that involved heating and pressurizing a graphite seed, which led to the creation of gem-quality diamonds, although initially plagued with some impurities. 

The chemical vapor deposition (CVD) technique, patented in the 1950s but not yielding satisfactory results at the time, saw refinements in the 1980s.

• Refinements and Economy

In the 1990s, improved high-pressure high-temperature (HPHT) and CVD processes resulted in higher quality diamonds and significantly lowered production costs.

By the 2000s, lab-grown diamonds became much more affordable, aided by multiple seed processes in CVD, reducing costs to as little as ₹15,000 per stone by the late 2010s.

This journey represents not only a technological evolution but an international scientific endeavor influenced by contributions from Russia and China, and foundational insights from historical figures like Isaac Newton.

The evolution of HPHT and CVD methods has made synthetic diamonds more accessible and affordable, but the question remains: how do they stack up against natural diamonds in terms of key characteristics?

Also Read: Lab-Grown Diamonds vs Natural Diamonds: Which to Buy?

Comparison of Synthetic and Natural Diamonds

Diamonds, whether natural or lab-created, are composed of crystallized carbon, making them outwardly similar. This makes them equally hard, scoring a perfect 10 on the MOHS hardness scale. Their refractive index of 2.42 ensures they both produce that legendary sparkle.

However, despite these uniform characteristics, their backgrounds could not be more different. Natural diamonds take billions of years to form deep within the Earth, later surfacing through volcanic eruptions.

On the flip side, synthetic diamonds spring to life swiftly in laboratories, using High Pressure-High Temperature (HPHT) or Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) methods.

While synthetic diamonds offer a significantly reduced price tag—20-40% less than natural ones—that's not the entirety of their appeal. For many, their environmental and ethical benefits play a crucial role in their selection.

Because of their synthetic origins, lab-grown diamonds can feature unique inclusions that are detectable only under a microscope. HPHT diamonds might show nickel-iron flux remnants, whereas CVD diamonds could have some black particles.

These subtle differences add a level of complication but also intrigue for those interested in the science behind these gems. To further understand these distinctions, it's important to look at the production methods that define synthetic diamonds.

Production Methods of Synthetic Diamonds

Creating lab-grown diamonds relies primarily on two processes, each with distinct characteristics.

• High-Pressure High-Temperature (HPHT)

The HPHT method replicates the intense heat and pressure conditions that occur deep inside the Earth where natural diamonds form.

This process uses massive presses such as the belt press, cubic press, or split-sphere (BARS) press to apply pressures up to 59,200 atm and temperatures between 1,300° to 1,600° C. 

Within this environment, a capsule containing carbon—typically graphite—a metal flux, and a minuscule diamond seed crystalizes to form a diamond.

Depending on the desired size and quality, this process may take anywhere from a few hours to several weeks. Post-growth heat treatments can further enhance the diamond's attributes like color and clarity and may also add fancy colors by incorporating elements such as boron or nickel.

• Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD)

The second method, Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD), employs a completely different approach.

It operates within a vacuum chamber and uses gasses like methane and hydrogen, heated to temperatures around 800° to 900° C. 

By ionizing these gasses—often with microwaves or lasers—plasma is created, which allows carbon atoms to deposit onto a substrate, usually a slice of diamond, building the diamond layer by layer.

This affords significant control over the eventual thickness and quality of the diamond. The CVD process takes from days to weeks. Its flexibility is notable, offering growth over larger areas and the potential to customize chemical properties and impurities.

Read in Detail: Differences and Comparison: CVD vs. HPHT Lab-Grown Diamonds

Furthermore, like in the HPHT process, post-formation heat treatments can improve the diamond's color, with elements like boron used to produce gourmet shades. With these enhancements, synthetic diamonds have found a variety of uses beyond just jewelry.

Applications of Synthetic Diamonds

Synthetic diamonds have found their way into numerous industries, offering unmatched benefits that have transformed manufacturing and electronics. Let's explore how these man-made gems are making a difference.

In the industrial sector, synthetic diamonds are invaluable due to their exceptional hardness and thermal conductivity. Manufacturing tools that cut, grind, and shape hard materials like metals, ceramics, and glass often rely on synthetic diamonds.

These diamonds provide a durable and consistent cutting surface when bonded to substrates like grinding wheels and saw blades. This makes them particularly useful in industries like metalworking, woodworking, stone cutting, and automotive manufacturing.

Their unmatched thermal properties also make synthetic diamonds excellent heat sinks in high-power electronics such as laser diodes, transistors, and computer chips. By efficiently dissipating heat, they enhance the performance and reliability of these components.

The jewelry industry, too, has embraced synthetic diamonds, positioning them as an ethical alternative to mined diamonds. Lab-grown diamonds avoid the environmental degradation and human rights issues often associated with traditional diamond mining.

Although the production process - especially the High-Pressure, High-Temperature method - consumes a considerable amount of energy, synthetic diamonds still stir ongoing ethical discussions. 

They offer consumers the allure and durability of natural diamonds without the associated ethical quandaries. With their increasing presence in the market, it becomes crucial to identify synthetic diamonds accurately to maintain transparency.

Identification of Synthetic Diamonds

Distinguishing synthetic from natural diamonds requires more than just a keen eye; it demands sophisticated tools and expert analysis. To the naked eye, lab-grown and natural diamonds appear remarkably similar.

However, specialized scrutiny using methods and technologies unveils unique characteristics indicative of either a natural or artificial origin.

• Techniques for Distinguishing Synthetic from Natural Diamonds

One of the primary techniques employed by gemologists is spectroscopy, which examines the fluorescence patterns visible when diamonds are exposed to ultraviolet light. 

Lab-grown diamonds typically exhibit different fluorescence responses compared to their natural counterparts, which is a key feature gemologists discern through this method.

Choose your pick from the rich collection of lab-grown diamonds at Everyday!

Additionally, the presence or absence of trace elements like nitrogen can also indicate whether a diamond is synthetic or natural. Natural diamonds often have tiny amounts of nitrogen, a marker gemologists seek using methods like FTIR (Fourier-transform infrared) spectroscopy to differentiate between the two.

Another tool in the gemologist's arsenal is the DiamondView tester. This device illuminates the diamond's internal growth patterns and inclusions, which are often unique in lab-grown stones.

For instance, HPHT (High Pressure High Temperature) diamonds can show symmetrical growth patterns, while CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition) diamonds might exhibit distinctive strain patterns and strong red fluorescence under UV light.

Lab-grown diamonds often come with identifiers that further assist in their differentiation. For example, some lab-grown diamonds contain inscriptions on their girdle that clearly state they are lab-grown.

Finally, the GIA iD100 screening device and similar technologies provide a quick means to screen not only individual diamonds but also collections of small stones, known as melee diamonds.

Also Read: Deciphering Diamond Certification - IGI and GIA

These devices, using advanced spectroscopic techniques, can swiftly and accurately categorize diamonds and simulants alike, ensuring that nothing goes unnoticed even among the tiniest of stones.

For jewelers without access to such technology, relying on grading reports and inscriptions is crucial until more comprehensive testing can be performed. As synthetic diamonds gain popularity, it's important to examine the market trends and consumer preferences shaping their demand.

Market Trends and Consumer Insights

The introduction of lab-grown diamonds has notably reshaped the diamond industry and presents both challenges and opportunities. 

With the ability to offer significant price reductions—sometimes ranging between 40-60% less than their natural counterparts—lab-grown diamonds have created a more budget-friendly option for consumers.

Lower production costs due to technological efficiencies and the absence of mining-related expenses provide their pricing advantage. As a result, the diamond market has seen a shift as consumers begin to consider not just the cost but also the ethical implications of their purchases.

This shift is particularly pronounced among younger consumers, such as Millennials and Generation Z, who are more inclined to seek ethically sourced products. 

Everyday also offers Type II diamonds that are ethically-sourced and are kind to the environment. 

Such preferences play into the growing appeal of lab-grown diamonds, which are touted as a sustainable alternative.

This dichotomy in consumer attitudes is shaping the future of the diamond market, challenging traditional diamond producers like De Beers to adjust their strategies.

They've responded by cutting prices for natural diamonds by up to 40% in response to declining demand, a clear indication of the competitive pressure exerted by lab-grown options.

Industry trends suggest that the lab-grown diamond market expands rapidly, with projections indicating significant growth in the coming years. According to reports, the synthetic diamond market could reach a valuation of over USD 41.6 billion by 2032.

As the market adjusts, many jewelers transition to a consignment model, reflecting a more cautious approach amid this evolving landscape.

With this discussed, let’s have a recap of the comparison.

Comparison Table: Synthetic vs. Natural Diamonds

When deciding between synthetic and natural diamonds, it’s crucial to understand their key differences. The table below highlights these factors to help you make an informed choice.

The Future Outlook and Impact of Lab-Grown Diamonds

Lab-grown diamonds are set to play a significant role in the future of the jewelry industry, as their sustainability and ethical appeal continue to draw attention. 

As more people seek responsible alternatives to traditional diamonds, it's becoming easier to find high-quality, affordable options.